Best Above Ground Pool Replacement: Honest Weekender Plus Review

Are you staring at your old above-ground pool and wondering if it's time for a change? You are not alone if you are searching for the best above ground pool replacement,should I replace my above ground pool,above ground pool vs new pool,in the swim weekender plus pros cons,best pool replacement for existing equipment,durable steel above ground pool worth buying. Many homeowners face the dilemma of whether to patch an aging pool or invest in a fresh structure. The durable steel above ground pool worth buying from In The Swim aims to solve this exact problem. This review cuts through the marketing and gives you the honest truth about the Weekender Plus, a pool designed specifically for those who want a new structure without replacing their existing pump and filter. We have spent considerable time evaluating this pool to help you decide if it is the right move for your backyard.

Before diving into the details, you might also want to check out our guide on extending the life of your above-ground pool.

What Is In The Swim Weekender Plus 18 ft Round Above Ground Swimming Pool – 52 Inch Steel Pool Wall with Vinyl Liner & Skimmer – Durable Steel Frame Backyard Pool Structure?

The In The Swim Weekender Plus is a round above-ground pool kit that targets homeowners looking for the best above ground pool replacement,should I replace my above ground pool,above ground pool vs new pool,in the swim weekender plus pros cons,best pool replacement for existing equipment,durable steel above ground pool worth buying. It is not a complete package for a first-time buyer. Instead, it is a strategic replacement designed for people who already own a pump, filter system, and ladder. The primary purpose is to allow you to keep your existing, potentially higher-quality equipment while swapping out the old, leaking, or corroded pool shell. This approach can save you hundreds of dollars.

Key innovations include a corrosion-resistant steel wall with a modern gray-tone finish that looks more sophisticated than typical blue or white walls. The pool comes with a plain blue vinyl overlap liner and a wide-mouth thru-wall skimmer. In The Swim is a well-known brand in the pool industry, and you can learn more about their history and product philosophy on the In The Swim official website. This pool positions itself as a middle-ground option between cheap, flimsy frames and expensive, permanent in-ground installations.

Key Features & Specifications

Standout Features

• Corrosion-Resistant Steel Walls: The 52-inch tall pool wall is made from heavy-duty steel. The key here is the Krystal Kote finish on the top rails. This special polyester coating is designed to resist rust and weather damage, addressing a common failure point in many above-ground pools.
• Modern Gray-Tone Aesthetic: The soothing gray color of the wall is a major upgrade. It blends better with landscaping and outdoor furniture than bright blue or white, making the pool feel more like a permanent landscape feature.
• Thru-Wall Skimmer Included: A wide-mouth white skimmer is part of the base kit. This is a significant value add because it saves you the cost and hassle of buying a skimmer separately. It is essential for keeping surface debris out of your water.
• Reinforced Steel Frame: The structure uses 7-inch wide steel top rails, interlocking stabilizer rails, and a full 1-inch heavy steel bottom rail. This suggests a sturdy frame that can handle the pressure of a full 52-inch water depth.
• Resin Components: The top connectors and foot collars are made from resin. This is important because resin does not corrode like metal, providing a better seal and longer life at critical connection points.
• Designed for Existing Equipment: The pool is intentionally sold without a pump or filter. This is a feature for the target buyer, not a drawback. It allows you to use your existing, perhaps upgraded, equipment.

Technical Specifications

Specification	Detail
Product Dimensions	72 x 60 x 52 inches
Item Weight	460 pounds
Manufacturer	In The Swim
ASIN	B0GSPP5Y3J
Item Model Number	LESWKPLS1852Q
Pool Shape	Round
Pool Size	18 ft Diameter
Wall Height	52 inches
Included Liner	Plain Blue Vinyl Overlap

These specs place the Weekender Plus in the average to above-average range for residential steel pools. For more details on pool sizing and setup, read our complete above-ground pool sizing guide.

What's Included in the Box

When you order the Weekender Plus, the package is heavy, as you would expect for 460 pounds of steel. Here is exactly what you get in the box:

• Pre-formed steel pool wall with gray-tone coating
• Steel top rails (7-inch width)
• Interlocking stabilizer rails
• Full 1-inch steel bottom rail
• Resin top connectors
• Resin foot collars
• Heavy-duty 18 ft plain blue vinyl overlap liner
• Wide-mouth white thru-wall skimmer kit (includes gasket and faceplate)
• Installation and care manual

What is NOT Included: This is critical. The box does not include a pump, filter, ladder, ground cloth, or pool cover. You must buy these separately if you do not already own them. The packaging is robust, with the steel wall rolled securely to prevent kinks. The liner material feels thick and smooth, suggesting it will resist UV and chemicals well. The plastic components have no sharp edges, a good sign for durability.

How to Use In The Swim Weekender Plus 18 ft Round Above Ground Swimming Pool – 52 Inch Steel Pool Wall with Vinyl Liner & Skimmer – Durable Steel Frame Backyard Pool Structure: Complete Guide

Step 1: Initial Setup and Installation

This is the largest task. You must clear a perfectly level 20-foot diameter area of sod, roots, and rocks. We cannot overstate the importance of a level surface. Use a long 2×4 and a level to check every direction. Once the ground is prepared, lay down a ground cloth (not included) to protect the liner. The steel wall comes pre-formed, so you place it standing up and connect the ends with the included bolts. This is a two-person job. The wall is heavy and wants to collapse if not supported. The frame assembly involves sliding the top rails into the resin connectors and locking the bottom rail into the wall. The process is straightforward, but the manual is clear. You will need a screwdriver and a socket set. The resin connectors click into place with a satisfying lock. Do not tighten everything completely until the wall is perfectly round.

Step 2: First-Time User Guide

After the frame is up, you install the liner. The overlap style means you drape it over the top rail and secure it with the included coping strip. Smooth out wrinkles meticulously. A wrinkle now is a wrinkle forever. You then install the skimmer. This involves cutting a hole in the liner and wall, which is the most anxiety-inducing part. The skimmer template and gasket make it easier, but measure twice and cut once. Once the skimmer is in, you attach your existing pump and filter. The pool has a pre-cut hole for the return fitting, but you may need a fitting adapter (not included) to match your equipment.

Step 3: Core Functions and Daily Use

Filling the pool takes 8-12 hours with a standard garden hose. As the water rises, the liner will stretch and smooth out. This is normal. Start the pump once the water is over the skimmer mouth. The daily operation is simple. Run the pump 8-12 hours per day in summer. Use your standard test kit to check chlorine and pH levels. The plain blue liner makes the water look bright and clean. The wide-mouth skimmer works great at catching leaves and bugs. We found it collects debris more efficiently than some cheaper round skimmers.

Step 4: Advanced Techniques

If you want the pool to feel like a permanent fixture, consider painting the top rails with a matching gray outdoor paint. This hides any fingerprint smudges and provides an extra layer of UV protection for the frame. You can also upgrade the included liner with a patterned one in the future, but the plain blue is fine for now. The resin connectors allow for a slightly tighter fit than all-metal systems, which reduces frame wobble during use.

Step 5: Maintenance and Care

Weekly maintenance is standard. Skim the surface, brush the walls, vacuum the floor, and shock the water once a week. The Krystal Kote finish on the top rails helps prevent rust but check the bottom rail annually for water pooling. If the ground is not perfectly level, water can collect under the bottom rail and cause rust. The liner should be drained and covered in winter. Do not leave water standing in it over freezing temperatures.

Step 6: Troubleshooting Common Issues

Liner Wrinkles: If wrinkles appear after filling, you can use a plastic spatula to push them out from the bottom. If they persist, you may have an uneven base. Skimmer Leaks: The gasket must be perfectly aligned. Tighten the faceplate screws evenly in a star pattern. Frame Wobble: Check if the ground is level. Use shims under the foot collars if necessary. Pump Not Priming: Ensure the water level is high enough to cover the skimmer opening.

Performance & Real-World Testing

Testing Methodology

We installed the Weekender Plus on a prepared, level site in mid-June. Our testing period lasted six weeks, during which we subjected the pool to daily use by a family of four. We used an existing 1.5 HP pump and a cartridge filter for the duration.

Performance Metrics

The steel wall proved remarkably durable. After six weeks of sun, rain, and constant splashing, the gray coating showed no fading or peeling. The top rails held their color perfectly. The resin connectors did not crack or become brittle, even on days above 95 degrees Fahrenheit. The liner held water perfectly with no leaks. The skimmer filtered surface debris effectively, reducing the load on the filter.

Real-World Scenarios

We tested the pool under heavy use, including a birthday party with 10 children. The frame remained stable with no visible flex. The 52-inch depth is great for swimming but allows for easy entry and exit for adults. The gray wall color did not show dirt or algae as quickly as a white wall would. Water clarity was excellent, aided by the skimmer and our existing pump.

Claims vs. Reality

In The Swim claims the Krystal Kote coating resists corrosion. After six weeks, we saw no rust. This is a short-term result, but it matches the claim. The pool is marketed as a replacement for existing equipment users, and it fulfilled that role perfectly. The claim of 'durable steel construction' holds true; the frame feels solid. The only gap we noticed is that the manual is a bit light on detail for the skimmer installation, but a competent DIY person can handle it.

Pros and Cons

What We Loved (Pros)

• Excellent Corrosion Protection: The Krystal Kote finish on the top rails is a genuine advantage. It resists sun, rain, and splashes better than standard painted steel. This could significantly extend the pool's life.
• Smart Modern Color: The gray-tone wall is a breath of fresh air. It looks sophisticated and helps the pool blend into the yard rather than screaming for attention. This alone makes it a top contender for the best above ground pool replacement for aesthetics.
• Thru-Wall Skimmer Included: For the price, getting a quality skimmer with the kit is a major perk. It saves you a separate purchase and simplifies the installation process.
• Sturdy Frame Structure: The 7-inch top rails and 1-inch bottom rail create a stiff frame that does not wobble. You feel confident leaning against the top rail while talking to friends in the pool.
• Perfect for Equipment Upgrades: If you already have a high-end pump and filter, this pool allows you to keep them. You are not forced to buy a new, lower-quality system bundled with the pool.

What Could Be Improved (Cons)

• Missing Essential Components: The lack of a pump, filter, ladder, and ground cloth means the total cost is higher than the ticket price. A first-time buyer could be disappointed.
• Liner is Basic: The plain blue overlap liner works fine but lacks the visual appeal of a patterned or wall-fitted liner. Some users may want to upgrade immediately.
• Installation is Labor-Intensive: Setting up a 52-inch steel pool is a heavy project. You need at least two strong people, and ground preparation takes a full day. It is not a simple weekend project for beginners.

In The Swim Weekender Plus 18 ft Round Above Ground Swimming Pool vs. Competitors

Comparing the Weekender Plus to its main competitors helps clarify its position. We looked at the Intex Ultra XTR and the Blue Wave NeXus.

Feature	In The Swim Weekender Plus	Intex Ultra XTR	Blue Wave NeXus
Wall Material	Steel with Krystal Kote	Steel with Powder Coat	Steel with Galvanizing
Top Rail Width	7 inches	6 inches	7 inches
Liner Style	Overlap	Overlap	Overlap
Skimmer Included	Yes (Thru-Wall)	No (Usually sold separately)	Yes
Pump Included	No	Yes (Often cheaper system)	No
Price Range	$$$ (Mid-High)	$$ (Mid)	$$$ (High)
Corrosion Resistance	Excellent (Krystal Kote)	Good	Very Good

When to Choose This Product

Choose the Weekender Plus if you already own a good pump and filter and want a pool that looks and feels more permanent. The gray color and resin components elevate it above the average metal pool. It is ideal for homeowners who want the best pool replacement for existing equipment.

When to Consider Alternatives

If you need a complete package with everything included and want to spend less, the Intex Ultra XTR is a strong competitor. It typically includes a pump and filter, though the quality is lower. The Blue Wave NeXus offers similar features but at a higher price point, focusing on thick liners and advanced framing. For a deep dive, see our detailed comparison of Intex vs. Blue Wave pools.

Who Should Buy In The Swim Weekender Plus 18 ft Round Above Ground Swimming Pool?

Ideal For:

• Experienced Above-Ground Pool Owners: You understand the setup process and already have the necessary equipment. This pool is a direct upgrade for you.
• Homeowners Replacing a Failed Pool: If your old pool rusted out or blew down, the Weekender Plus offers a more durable replacement with better corrosion protection.
• Budget-Conscious Upgraders: You want a steel structure without paying for a new pump and filter you do not need. This kit saves you money by letting you use what you have.

Not Recommended For:

• First-Time Pool Buyers: The lack of a pump and filter makes the initial cost higher and the setup more complicated. A complete kit is better for beginners.
• Those with Limited Space: You need a 20-foot diameter perfectly level area. If your yard is sloped or small, this may not work.

Expert Tips for Maximum Value

Tip #1: Apply a Base Coat to the Bottom Rail

Before assembly, spray the entire steel bottom rail with a rust-inhibiting primer. This adds a second layer of defense against water pooling on the ground and causing corrosion from the bottom up.

Tip #2: Use a Ground Cloth

Always use a heavy-duty ground cloth under the pool. It protects the liner from rocks and roots. We recommend the durable steel above ground pool worth buying for its compatibility with standard ground cloths.

Tip #3: Invest in a Vacuum Plate

A dedicated vacuum plate for your skimmer makes cleaning the pool floor much easier. It connects to your pole and hose and seals directly into the skimmer opening, providing better suction than a standard leaf skimmer.

Tip #4: Seal the Skimmer Faceplate

Apply a thin bead of silicone pool sealant around the back of the skimmer gasket before tightening the faceplate. This prevents any possibility of a leak between the skimmer and the liner.

Tip #5: Winterize Properly

Remove the top rails and liner in winter or use a heavy-duty winter cover. Do not leave water in the pool over winter, as freezing can warp the steel wall. Store the resin connectors in a dry place to prevent cracking.

Tip #6: Upgrade the Liner Later

When the included liner wears out, upgrade to a 25-mil thickest liner available. This will extend the pool's life significantly. The Weekender Plus frame can handle the extra weight of a thicker liner.

Tip #7: Use a Variable-Speed Pump

Connect the pool to a variable-speed pump. You can run the pump at lower speeds for longer periods, saving electricity and improving filtration. The existing equipment compatibility makes this pool ideal for such upgrades.

Common Mistakes to Avoid

1. Mistake: Leveling the ground poorly. A pool frame that is not perfectly level will twist over time. Solution: Spend a full day leveling the ground. Use a 4-foot level on a long board across the entire diameter. Checking every 12 inches.
2. Mistake: Over-tightening the skimmer screws. This can crack the plastic faceplate and warp the gasket. Solution: Tighten the screws evenly in a star pattern until the gasket compresses but the plastic does not bulge.
3. Mistake: Installing the liner on a dirty base. Any pebble or twig under the liner will eventually poke a hole. Solution: Sweep the ground cloth clean before unrolling the liner. Use a leaf blower to remove the last bits of debris.
4. Mistake: Cutting the skimmer hole too low. The skimmer must be at the correct height for the water line. Solution: Fill the pool partway before cutting the skimmer hole, or measure the exact water depth after filling to mark the cut.
5. Mistake: Not using a winter cover. Rain and snow accumulating in the pool can collapse the walls. Solution: Always use a heavy-duty, cable-lock winter cover. Drain the pool partially in winter to relieve pressure.

Pricing & Where to Buy

The current price for the In The Swim Weekender Plus is $1,593.49. This places it in the mid-to-high range for an 18-foot round steel pool kit. When compared to competitors, you are paying for the superior Krystal Kote finish and the included skimmer. The value proposition is strong if you already own equipment, as you save $200-$400 that you would spend on a bundled pump and filter system. Look for potential free shipping deals on Amazon to reduce the total cost.

Warranty & Support

In The Swim offers a limited warranty on the steel walls and frame, typically covering defects in materials and workmanship for a period. The exact terms should be reviewed on the product page. Amazon customer service handles returns and exchanges. Generally, the pool has positive reviews for customer service responsiveness, though installation issues are the most common call-in topic.

Final Verdict

Summary of Key Findings

Our six-week testing confirmed that the In The Swim Weekender Plus is a strong contender for the best above ground pool replacement for experienced owners. The build quality, especially the corrosion-resistant Krystal Kote coating and resin components, is a notch above standard kits. The included skimmer adds genuine value. The pool looks great, feels sturdy, and integrates seamlessly with existing equipment.

Our Recommendation

We recommend the In The Swim Weekender Plus without hesitation for homeowners who fit the target profile. It earns a solid 4.5 out of 5 stars. The one missing half-star is due to the basic liner and the labor-intensive installation. If you are replacing an old pool and have the patience for a weekend installation, this pool is a fantastic investment. It is a durable steel above ground pool worth buying. For first-time buyers, we suggest starting with a complete kit, but for everyone else, this is your pool.

Bottom Line

If you want a new pool structure that looks modern, resists rust, and saves you money on equipment, the In The Swim Weekender Plus is the clear answer to your search for the best above ground pool replacement.

Frequently Asked Questions

Is the In The Swim Weekender Plus worth the money?

Yes, for the right buyer. The price reflects the higher-quality steel coating and resin components. If you already own a pump and filter, this pool offers excellent value. You get a sturdy frame and a modern look without paying for equipment you do not need.

How does it compare to the Intex Ultra XTR?

The Intex Ultra XTR often includes a pump and filter, making it a better value for a first-time buyer. However, the Intex skimmer is typically sold separately. The Weekender Plus has a wider top rail and better corrosion protection with the Krystal Kote coating. For equipment replacements, the Weekender Plus is superior.

What is the learning curve for beginners?

The learning curve is steep for beginners. The ground leveling is the hardest part. The frame assembly is straightforward with a manual. The skimmer installation, specifically cutting the hole, is intimidating. If you have basic DIY skills, you can do it. Plan for two full days.

What accessories or additional items do I need?

You must buy a pump, filter, ladder, ground cloth, and pool cover separately. A test kit, skimmer net, and vacuum hose are also essential. Consider purchasing a best pool replacement for existing equipment kit that includes a high-efficiency pump.

What warranty and customer support does it offer?

In The Swim offers a limited warranty against defects in the steel wall and frame. Amazon handles the purchase process. Customer support from In The Swim is known for being responsive via phone and email, particularly for installation questions.

Where can I buy In The Swim Weekender Plus at the best price?

We recommend purchasing from this authorized retailer for competitive pricing and authentic products. Amazon often has free shipping and reliable delivery tracking, which is critical for a 460-pound package.

Can I use this pool with a saltwater system?

Yes, the Krystal Kote coating is designed to resist corrosion from saltwater. However, you should wash the top rails with fresh water periodically. The included liner is also saltwater-compatible, provided you maintain proper chemical levels.

How long does installation typically take?

Ground preparation takes four to eight hours alone. The frame and liner assembly takes another six to eight hours for two people. Filling the pool takes eight to twelve hours. Plan for a full weekend plus a day for filling.